Skip to main content
The Hickory League

Rules of Play, Provisional Edition 0.9

Ratifies team competition (3v3 lineups revealed together by the referee, Scramble driver rotation and unified team scoring), club eligibility with a referee inspection before every match, the official T-Stick dimensions, anchor, handle and ribbons, and the referee's procedures for a displaced, damaged or disputed T-Stick. An experimental wood-on-wood crossbar remains a proposal. Supersedes edition 0.8.

Status
Provisional. Not yet in force.
Effective date
To be set on ratification
Clauses
123 ratified, 13 pending, 16 proposed

1The sport

  1. 1.1

    The Hickory League is a competitive sport played with traditional golf equipment. Players compete to strike a portable physical target, known as the T-Stick, in the fewest adjusted strokes.

  2. 1.2

    Competition is match play between two players. Holes, rounds and matches are won, halved or drawn as set out in these rules.

  3. 1.3

    A player's adjusted score for a hole is their physical strokes plus any penalty strokes.

  4. 1.4

    The Hickory League has two playing environments. Field Play uses a portable, ground-anchored T-Stick in an approved playing area. Course Play uses an existing golf course with a cup-mounted T-Stick (section 15). Unless a rule says otherwise, these rules govern Field Play.

2Equipment

  1. 2.1

    Each player carries exactly four clubs.

  2. 2.2

    One club is designated the Establishing Stick (EST). The remaining three are designated Playing Clubs.

  3. 2.3

    The Establishing Stick may not be used during ordinary competitive hole play. Once the hole begins, the three Playing Clubs are the only clubs a player may use.

  4. 2.4

    Only wood-shafted clubs may be used, in Field Play and Course Play alike. Clubs with steel, graphite, composite or any other non-wooden shafts are not allowed. This applies to all four designated clubs.

  5. 2.5

    Eligible clubs are authentic historical wood-shafted golf clubs, modern reproductions fitted with genuine wooden shafts, and restored vintage clubs that meet these equipment requirements.

  6. 2.6

    Club heads must be traditional in style: wooden or metal heads, authentic historical heads, or modern reproductions consistent with hickory-era design. Modern non-heritage head designs are not permitted.

  7. 2.7

    Permitted grips are original historical grips, leather grips and modern replacement grips, including rubber. Every grip must be safe, securely fitted and consistent with the heritage character of the club.

  8. 2.8

    Each player designates exactly four eligible clubs: in Field Play, one Establishing Stick and three Playing Clubs; in Course Play, one Start Stick and three Playing Clubs.

  9. 2.9

    Before every match, the referee inspects all four designated clubs of every player and confirms genuine wooden shafts, compliant traditional-style wooden or metal heads, compliant grips and no visible safety defects.

  10. 2.10

    Approved clubs are recorded on the official match sheet. A questionable or noncompliant club must be replaced or excluded before competition, and a match does not begin until every player has four approved clubs. Only approved, recorded clubs may be used during the match.

3Use of tees

  1. 3.1

    Golf tees are permitted for establishing (EST) shots.

  2. 3.2

    Golf tees are prohibited for the opening competitive shot and for all later competitive shots.

4Establishing the hole

  1. 4.1

    The T-Stick is positioned in an approved playing area.

  2. 4.2

    Both players perform an establishing drive-off with their Establishing Sticks, hitting away from the T-Stick.

  3. 4.3

    The longest valid establishing shot determines the initial tee location.

  4. 4.4

    The winner of the drive-off chooses PLAY, PUSH or CHALLENGE.

  5. 4.5

    PLAY: accept the established starting position and begin the hole. Both players begin the competitive hole from there, playing back toward the T-Stick, and the drive-off winner takes the first shot.

  6. 4.6

    An establishing drive-off is held before every hole, from the T-Stick's current position. When a hole is complete, the winner of that hole chooses the direction of the next drive-off and drives first. This continues hole by hole until the round is complete.

  7. 4.7

    Proposed: both players begin competitive play from the same established tee location, without golf tees.

  8. 4.8

    Proposed: establishing (EST) shots are excluded from competitive stroke totals.

  9. 4.9

    After a halved hole, the player who drove second in that hole's drive-off chooses the direction of the next drive-off and drives first.

  10. 4.10

    On the first hole of a match, the players may hit their establishing shots at the same time, or choose between themselves who hits first. Establishing shots on the first hole may be hit in any direction, a full 360 degrees around the T-Stick, provided the public and bystanders are safe.

  11. 4.11

    Who drives first after a halved hole whose establishing shots were hit at the same time has not yet been decided.

  12. 4.12

    PUSH: the drive-off winner elects to extend the hole by hitting another establishing shot from the established starting position, to move the start farther from the T-Stick, and takes the first competitive shot. Play begins from where that ball comes to rest; the extra shot may leave a worse starting position.

  13. 4.13

    Proposed: CHALLENGE involves the opponent: the drive-off winner lets the other player hit another establishing shot, play begins from where that ball comes to rest, and that player takes the first competitive shot. The exact mechanics are not yet confirmed.

  14. 4.14

    If an additional establishing shot is lost or leaves play, the ball is dropped near where it was seen to leave play, with no penalty, and the hole begins from there.

5Playing the hole

  1. 5.1

    Players take alternating turns. Only one player plays a shot at a time.

  2. 5.2

    Both players must receive equal opportunities to complete the hole.

  3. 5.3

    If the first player strikes the T-Stick, the second player receives any remaining equal-turn opportunity before the hole is decided.

  4. 5.4

    After PLAY or PUSH, the drive-off winner takes the first competitive shot. Who goes first after CHALLENGE depends on its mechanics, which are not yet confirmed (rule 4.13).

  5. 5.5

    Proposed: players alternate physical shots. Exceptions apply after a player completes the hole or an official suspends play. Equal-turn protection must be preserved.

  6. 5.6

    Proposed: equal-turn protection is measured by physical shots, while the hole winner is determined by adjusted strokes, including penalties.

6Completing the hole

  1. 6.1

    To complete the hole, the ball must physically strike the T-Stick.

  2. 6.2

    Direct contact, contact after a bounce, and contact while rolling all count.

  3. 6.3

    A ball that stops near the T-Stick without striking it does not complete the hole.

  4. 6.4

    The player with the fewest adjusted strokes to valid T-Stick contact wins the hole.

  5. 6.5

    If both players achieve valid T-Stick contact in the same number of adjusted strokes, the hole is halved.

  6. 6.6

    Each player may take a maximum of 12 physical strokes on a hole.

  7. 6.7

    Penalty strokes do not count toward the maximum of 12 physical strokes.

  8. 6.8

    A player who reaches 12 physical strokes without striking the T-Stick has not completed the hole.

  9. 6.9

    Proposed: if neither player strikes the T-Stick within 12 physical strokes, the hole is recorded as X and both players receive an NC (non-completion) designation.

  10. 6.10

    Proposed: if one player strikes the T-Stick and the other does not, the player who strikes the T-Stick wins the hole.

7Scoring a hole

  1. 7.1

    Each hole is recorded on the official scorecard as 1 (won), 0 (lost) or X (halved).

  2. 7.2

    The symbol ½ is not displayed on official scorecards. Internally, X represents half a hole point for each player. X means a halved hole, not a missing score.

8Rounds

  1. 8.1

    A round consists of exactly three holes.

  2. 8.2

    The player with the most hole points wins the round. Equal hole points produce a drawn round.

  3. 8.3

    A round win earns one round point, a drawn round earns half a round point, and a round loss earns none.

9Matches

  1. 9.1

    A regular-season match consists of exactly three mandatory rounds, making exactly nine holes in a completed match.

  2. 9.2

    All nine holes must be played, even if one player wins the first two rounds.

  3. 9.3

    The player with the most round points wins the match. Equal round points produce a drawn match.

10League standings

  1. 10.1

    A match win earns three league points, a draw earns one, and a loss earns none.

  2. 10.2

    League points are separate from hole points, round points and stroke counts.

  3. 10.3

    Proposed: players level on league points are separated by, in order, head-to-head results, round differential, hole differential, then total match wins.

  4. 10.4

    Team leagues and individual leagues are separate: team matches count only toward team league standings, and individual matches only toward individual league standings. Team formats are set out in section 18.

11Playoffs and championships

  1. 11.1

    An elimination match must produce a winner.

  2. 11.2

    Proposed: drawn elimination matches continue with sudden-death extra holes, with equal-turn protection remaining in effect.

12Penalties and relief

  1. 12.1

    THL uses golf-style penalty stroke accounting. A player's adjusted score is their physical strokes plus their penalty strokes.

  2. 12.2

    Penalty strokes are counted in sequence with physical strokes. For example, if a player's first shot is stroke 1 and they then incur a one-stroke penalty, that penalty is stroke 2 and their next physical shot is stroke 3.

  3. 12.3

    Penalty strokes increase the player's running score but do not use a physical turn.

  4. 12.4

    There is no out-of-bounds penalty. If a player can find their ball, it is played where it lies, with no penalty.

  5. 12.5

    If a player cannot find their ball, it is a lost ball, and the player receives a one-stroke penalty.

  6. 12.6

    After a lost ball, the player must drop a ball from waist height within one Establishing Stick length of the spot where the ball was last seen, and play on from the drop.

  7. 12.7

    For example, if a player's first shot cannot be found, they receive one penalty stroke, drop a ball, and their next shot is stroke 3.

  8. 12.8

    The exact permitted drop area and drop procedure are subject to venue regulations.

  9. 12.9

    These relief rules are specific to THL and supersede conventional golf relief procedures during THL competition.

  10. 12.10

    A ball is lost if it is not found within two minutes of the start of the search.

  11. 12.11

    Bad lie: a player whose ball lies in a bad spot may take relief by dropping a ball from waist height within one Establishing Stick length of the bad spot.

  12. 12.12

    Proposed, wrong club: two penalty strokes; the shot is invalidated and replayed.

  13. 12.13

    Proposed, accidental T-Stick displacement: the T-Stick is restored, with no penalty.

  14. 12.14

    Proposed, deliberate T-Stick interference: loss of the hole.

  15. 12.15

    Proposed, dangerous shot: play is suspended immediately for official review.

  16. 12.16

    If there is nothing but bad spots within that length, as in a flood, the player may place the ball farther back, as far as they wish, but may not improve their lie: for example, a ball in the rough may not be placed on the fairway.

  17. 12.17

    Bad-lie relief costs no penalty stroke.

  18. 12.18

    A found ball that lies somewhere unsafe or outside the authorized playing area is played as it lies if it is playable. If it is not, the player takes bad-lie relief under rules 12.11 and 12.16.

13Safety

  1. 13.1

    Competitive play takes place only at authorized venues suitable for the sport.

  2. 13.2

    Players may not hit simultaneously, except that establishing shots may be hit at the same time.

  3. 13.3

    The playing area must be clear before any shot is played.

  4. 13.4

    Officials may suspend, cancel or forfeit a match for safety reasons.

  5. 13.5

    THL's guidance is that forfeited and abandoned matches should be recorded as administrative results, without completed-hole statistics. Their exact scoring and standings consequences have not yet been defined.

    Pending ratificationOQ-012: Forfeits

14The THL Tommy Stick (T-Stick)

  1. 14.1

    The Official THL Tommy Stick, called the T-Stick for short, is the target used in competition: a tall, upright, T-shaped wooden target with one vertical shaft and one horizontal crossbar at the top. It may also be called the T or the stick. In these rules it is called the T-Stick.

  2. 14.2

    One T-Stick is used for all three holes of each round and all nine holes of a regular-season match. Multiple targets are not used.

  3. 14.3

    The T-Stick is both the target players attempt to strike and the indicator of the current round and hole.

  4. 14.4

    The official T-Stick stands 36 to 48 inches above ground. Its rounded wooden vertical shaft is about 2 inches in diameter, and its wooden crossbar is 18 to 24 inches long and about 1 inch in diameter. Hickory is the preferred material. These are approved dimensional ranges, not a finished manufacturing drawing: final manufacturing tolerances require prototype testing.

  5. 14.5

    The crossbar must be structurally secure and must remain captive during installation, play, transport and removal. It must not be able to slide out or become a projectile.

  6. 14.6

    The T-Stick must remain secured in its designated position during play.

  7. 14.7

    The T-Stick has an integrated metal helical screw anchor and a dedicated installation handle. The anchor is screwed into suitable soil using the built-in handle, holds the T-Stick upright and stable during play, and can be removed for repeated installation. No separate installation tool is required. The handle must not interfere with play or restrict the crossbar's movement. Final anchor dimensions, depth and holding strength, and the handle's construction and placement, require prototype development and testing.

  8. 14.8

    The following engineering matters have not yet been decided: the exact crossbar-to-bore dimensions and tolerances; how the crossbar is kept captive, including an experimental wood-on-wood friction fit that is not approved; reinforcement around the bore; installation torque limits; whether a temporary crossbar lock is needed; whether crossbar movement produces the intended sound; and long-term wear and durability.

  9. 14.9

    The T-Stick stays in the same location for every hole of a round. When a round is complete, the winner of that round chooses whether the T-Stick stays where it is for the next round or is re-established in a new location. Keeping the same location for all three rounds is preferred, but it is not required. After a drawn round, the T-Stick stays where it is.

  10. 14.10

    The T-Stick is marked with ribbons, not banners. Ribbons are tied directly onto the T-Stick, with no screws, hooks or other hardware. Where the ribbon is tied shows the hole within the round: on the left arm of the crossbar for hole 1, on the shaft towards the top for hole 2 and on the right arm of the crossbar for hole 3. Only the current hole's ribbon is displayed.

  11. 14.11

    Proposed: the color of the ribbon shows the round: red for round 1, white for round 2 and blue for round 3, chosen to stand out. Match holes 1 to 3 would be red ribbons on the left, middle and right; holes 4 to 6 white; and holes 7 to 9 blue.

  12. 14.12

    Left and right are defined from the viewpoint of a player facing the T-Stick from the approved competitive starting location. This orientation stays the same for the whole hole and must be preserved whenever the T-Stick is restored.

  13. 14.13

    Ribbons are fabric, tied on with traditional knots; no separate attachment fasteners are required. The referee checks that the knots are secure. Ribbons and knots must not restrict the crossbar's intended movement or interfere with safe operation.

  14. 14.14

    A player closes a hole when their legally played ball physically contacts any part of the wooden T-Stick: the vertical shaft, the horizontal crossbar, either exposed end of the crossbar, or the wooden connection area where the crossbar passes through the shaft.

  15. 14.15

    Contact may occur directly in flight, after bouncing or after rolling. The T-Stick does not need to fall over, move or make a sound for contact to count: a valid hit counts even if no sound is heard. A near miss does not count.

  16. 14.16

    The ball must hit the wooden T-Stick itself. Contact with a ribbon, identification marker, attachment accessory, the ground anchor, a cup adapter or any other non-wooden equipment alone does not count and does not complete the hole: play continues.

  17. 14.17

    Once valid contact occurs, that player's hole attempt is complete, and their physical and penalty strokes give their adjusted score. Closing a hole for one player does not end the hole: the opponent receives any remaining equal-turn opportunity before the result is determined.

  18. 14.18

    The referee has final authority to decide disputed contact with the T-Stick, using direct observation, any available video and other reliable evidence. Contact must be reasonably established: uncertainty alone does not count as a hit. Contact with the wooden shaft or crossbar counts, including after bouncing or rolling, and no sound or visible movement is required. Contact with ribbons, the anchor or other attachments alone does not count.

  19. 14.19

    A player may not deliberately move, rotate, knock over or otherwise alter the position of the T-Stick, or interfere with an opponent's attempt to strike it.

  20. 14.20

    The penalty for deliberate interference has not yet been ratified. Loss of hole is proposed (Rule 12.14); interfering with an opponent's attempt is not yet covered by any proposal.

    Pending ratificationOQ-009: Penalties and relief
  21. 14.21

    If the T-Stick is accidentally displaced, the referee immediately suspends play, restores it to its original approved position and orientation, and checks that it is stable and safe. Play then resumes with the existing turn order. No penalty is assessed.

  22. 14.22

    If exact restoration is impossible, the referee establishes the closest fair equivalent position and records the adjustment on the match sheet.

  23. 14.23

    If the T-Stick is damaged during play, the referee suspends play and assesses the damage, and the T-Stick is repaired or replaced as necessary in its original approved position and orientation. Once the referee confirms the target is safe and stable, play resumes. Completed shots remain valid, and physical strokes, penalty strokes and turn order are unchanged. Ordinary accidental damage carries no penalty; deliberate interference is governed by rules 14.19 and 14.20.

  24. 14.24

    Prototype engineering and manufacturing safety testing are separate from the referee's routine inspection. The T-Stick has not yet been engineering-tested, impact-tested, field-tested or certified for official play, and the tests required, covering soil conditions, anchor depth, underground utilities, stability under ball impact, resistance to tipping, wood splitting, crossbar retention under impact, structural fatigue and safe removal, have not yet been decided.

  25. 14.25

    The T-Stick stays in the same position unless it is moved between rounds. When it is moved, it may be placed anywhere in the approved playing area that is safe to play.

  26. 14.26

    Proposed: a natural-wood finish, rounded crossbar ends, and one wooden upper assembly shared by Field Play and Course Play with interchangeable mounting systems.

  27. 14.27

    The crossbar moves slightly and observably in its bore, with no excessive looseness, no binding and no risk of detachment, and stays captive during competitive play. Exact bore dimensions and tolerances require prototype testing. This standard is subject to future design review.

  28. 14.28

    If the anchor cannot be safely installed at the intended target location, the referee selects the nearest suitable alternative location, preserving the intended hole layout and competitive conditions as closely as reasonably possible, and approves it before the establishing phase begins. The T-Stick must be securely installed before play. A freestanding weighted base is not an approved alternative.

  29. 14.29

    Before every hole, the referee visually inspects the installed T-Stick for an upright position, visible anchor instability, leaning, damage, improper installation and any other visible safety concern. Visible instability must be corrected before play. No physical push or pull test or measured deflection test is required for this routine inspection.

  30. 14.30

    What happens if a ribbon is damaged during play has not yet been decided.

    Pending ratificationOQ-033: Damage during play

15Course Play: Conventional Events

  1. 15.1

    Course Play is the THL playing environment that uses an existing golf course and its conventional hole layout. Course Play events may also be called Conventional Events or Opens.

  2. 15.2

    Whether THL can officially sanction Course Play events has not yet been decided. Course Play is not currently offered at any golf course, and the T-Stick is not an approved replacement for conventional golf flagsticks.

  3. 15.3

    Every Course Play event begins each hole from the blue tee markers of the golf course.

  4. 15.4

    Which tees are used at a course without blue tee markers has not yet been decided.

  5. 15.5

    Each player carries exactly four designated clubs: one Start Stick and three Playing Clubs. The Start Stick is the player's designated fourth club.

  6. 15.6

    The Start Stick is used for the opening tee shot of each hole. After the opening tee shot, players use only their three Playing Clubs.

  7. 15.7

    Course Play does not use a competitive drive-off to establish a starting location. The establishing rules of section 4 apply only to Field Play.

  8. 15.8

    Whether the opening tee shot counts as a stroke toward the adjusted score, and which player tees off first, have not yet been decided.

  9. 15.9

    The course's existing hole location is used, with an approved THL T-Stick installed in place of the flagstick.

  10. 15.10

    Proposed: the conventional flagstick is temporarily removed and a compatible THL target assembly is mounted in the existing cup, with explicit permission from the course operator. No drilling, ground penetration or permanent modification of the putting green is permitted.

  11. 15.11

    The cup adapter, its compatibility with different cups and flagstick systems, its inspection and approval, course-operator permission, liability and insurance, course operating policies and the protection of putting surfaces have not yet been decided.

  12. 15.12

    Any part of the wooden T-Stick counts as valid target contact, as set out in rules 14.14 to 14.16, and closes that player's hole attempt.

  13. 15.13

    The equal-turn opportunity and adjusted-stroke scoring principles of these rules apply to Course Play.

  14. 15.14

    Field Play mechanics not set out in this section do not automatically apply to Course Play. Not yet decided: whether holes 1–9 or 1–18 are played; whether three-round scoring and ribbons apply; how hazards, out of bounds and penalties apply; how players complete a hole after target contact; and how the T-Stick is installed and removed between groups.

16Referees

  1. 16.1

    A referee (ref) is present at every match, in Field Play and Course Play, to control the pace of play and to apply these rules.

  2. 16.2

    Referees dress all in white, with a green or gold cap.

  3. 16.3

    Pace-of-play standards, including any time limits and what happens when play is too slow, and how referees are appointed, qualified and reviewed, have not yet been decided.

17The THL Standard of Dress

  1. 17.1

    Traditional hickory-era attire, inspired by golf of about 1900 to 1930, is mandatory for every player at official THL-sanctioned events, championships and tournaments, in Field Play and Course Play alike.

  2. 17.2

    Headwear: a traditional cabbie cap, newsboy cap or period-appropriate flat cap. Baseball caps and modern performance golf caps do not meet the standard.

  3. 17.3

    Shirt: a collared dress shirt. Traditional button-down styling is preferred, and long sleeves are encouraged but not required. Modern athletic golf polos do not meet the standard.

  4. 17.4

    Vest: a traditional vest or waistcoat, worn throughout competition, subject to approved safety and accessibility accommodations. Tweed, wool, cotton and other heritage materials are encouraged.

  5. 17.5

    Trousers: traditional plus fours or golf knickerbockers, ending at or just below the knee so the long socks remain visible. Modern golf shorts, jeans and full-length golf trousers do not meet the standard.

  6. 17.6

    Socks: knee-high golf socks or stockings, in traditional argyle, ribbed or solid designs, worn to complement the plus fours or knickerbockers.

  7. 17.7

    Footwear: golf-appropriate shoes that meet course safety and surface requirements. Modern golf shoes are permitted; traditional leather or period-inspired golf shoes are strongly recommended.

  8. 17.8

    Community leagues and casual THL events are exempt from the mandatory standard. Traditional attire is encouraged and modern golf clothing is permitted, and no player is penalized for not wearing heritage attire. Appropriate footwear and venue safety rules still apply.

  9. 17.9

    At sanctioned events, players must meet the standard before competition begins. Event officials may inspect attire at registration or check-in. A player who does not meet the standard is given the opportunity to correct it before starting; unresolved noncompliance may result in denial of participation in that event.

  10. 17.10

    Clothing never results in a stroke penalty or any other scoring penalty.

  11. 17.11

    Reasonable accommodations are made for disability, medical needs, religion and safety, and the standard is applied consistently and without discrimination.

  12. 17.12

    The referee approves accommodations to the standard. Whether an event is sanctioned or community is decided by the local league commissioner or the referee.

  13. 17.13

    Championships and events that count toward league standings are always official THL-sanctioned events. For any other event, the league official decides.

18Team Play

  1. 18.1

    THL has two team formats: the 3v3 team match, with three players a side, and the Scramble, with two players a side.

  2. 18.2

    In a 3v3 team match, each player plays one of the match's three rounds against a player from the other team.

  3. 18.3

    Before a 3v3 team match begins, each team privately submits its three-player round order to the referee. The referee reveals both lineups at the same time, and only once both have been received. The matchups for rounds 1, 2 and 3 are then locked: each player plays exactly one round, and the lineups may not be changed under the standard procedure.

  4. 18.4

    A Scramble is played two against two. Both players on a team play each shot, the team chooses the better ball, and both play their next shot from there. The team always plays its best ball.

  5. 18.5

    Establishing shots are unchanged in team play. In a 3v3 team match, the two players playing the round drive off as in section 4. In a Scramble, each team hits one establishing shot, and the drive-off is decided as in section 4.

  6. 18.6

    In a Scramble, each team takes one establishing drive-off shot per hole, hit by its designated driver. Each team chooses its driver for the first hole, and teammates then alternate on every following hole: the same player may not take the team's drive-off on consecutive holes.

  7. 18.7

    3v3 matches and Scrambles are scored the same way: three mandatory rounds of three holes, nine holes in all, every hole played. A round win earns 1 round point, a drawn round 0.5 to each team and a loss none. The team with more round points wins the match; equal round points draw it. A match win earns 3 league points, a draw 1 and a loss none. Team standings are kept separately from individual standings, and team results never count toward individual league points.

  8. 18.8

    In a Scramble, the designated driver for the hole also takes any additional establishing shot assigned to their team. After PLAY there is no additional shot. After PUSH, the winning team's designated driver takes it and that team plays first. After CHALLENGE, the opposing team's designated driver takes it and that team plays first. The additional shot sets the shared starting location, even if it leaves a worse position.

  9. 18.9

    Exceptional substitution procedures for a locked 3v3 lineup have not yet been decided.

    Pending ratificationOQ-059: 3v3 substitutions

Open questions and proposed rulings

These matters are not fully confirmed. Proposed rulings are shown so players know what is under consideration, but they are not binding until THL confirms them. Each pending or proposed clause above links to the question it depends on.

OQ-001

PLAY, PUSH and CHALLENGEPartially confirmed

What are the exact mechanics of CHALLENGE in singles play?

Confirmed

  • PLAY: accept the established starting position and begin the hole; the drive-off winner takes the first shot (Rules 4.5, 5.4).
  • PUSH: the drive-off winner hits another establishing shot from the established start to extend the hole farther from the T-Stick, and takes the first shot (Rules 4.12, 5.4).
  • A lost additional establishing shot is dropped near where it was seen to leave play, with no penalty, and the hole begins there (Rule 4.14).
  • In a Scramble, CHALLENGE gives the additional establishing shot to the opposing team's designated driver, and that team plays first (Rule 18.8).

Proposed, not binding

  • CHALLENGE involves the opponent: the other player hits another establishing shot, play begins where it lands, and that player goes first. THL has said the exact mechanics still need to be confirmed.
OQ-002

Drive-off frequency and orderPartially confirmed

Who drives first after a halved hole whose establishing shots were hit at the same time?

Confirmed

  • An establishing drive-off is held before every hole, from the T-Stick's current position.
  • The winner of the previous hole chooses the direction of the next drive-off and drives first.
  • After a halved hole, the player who drove second in that hole's drive-off chooses the direction and drives first.
  • On the first hole of a match, the players may hit at the same time or choose who hits first, in any direction (360 degrees) that is safe for the public and bystanders.
OQ-003

Starting locationProposed

Where do the players begin competitive play after the drive-off?

Proposed, not binding

  • Both players begin competitive play from the same established tee location.
  • No golf tees are permitted.
OQ-004

Establishing strokesProposed

Do establishing (EST) shots count toward competitive stroke totals?

Proposed, not binding

  • EST shots are excluded from competitive stroke totals.
OQ-006

Turn exceptionsProposed

When may the alternation of turns be varied?

Proposed, not binding

  • Players alternate physical shots.
  • Exceptions apply after a player completes the hole or an official suspends play.
  • Equal-turn protection must be preserved.
OQ-007

Penalty fairnessProposed

When penalty strokes apply, how is equal-turn protection measured, and how is the hole winner decided?

Proposed, not binding

  • Equal-turn protection is measured by physical shots.
  • Hole winners are determined by adjusted strokes, including penalties.
OQ-008

Neither player hits the T-StickPartially confirmed

How is a hole resolved when one or both players fail to strike the T-Stick?

Confirmed

  • Maximum 12 physical strokes per player per hole.

Proposed, not binding

  • If neither player strikes the T-Stick within 12 physical strokes, the hole is recorded as X.
  • Both players receive an NC (non-completion) designation.
  • If one player strikes the T-Stick and the other does not, the player who strikes the T-Stick wins.
OQ-009

Penalties and reliefPartially confirmed

Which penalties and relief procedures apply beyond a lost ball, including for deliberately interfering with the T-Stick or with an opponent's attempt to strike it?

Confirmed

  • Traditional golf-style penalty accounting.
  • There is no out-of-bounds penalty: a ball that can be found is played where it lies.
  • Lost ball: a one-stroke penalty, and the player must drop a ball.
  • Bad lie: free relief by dropping from waist height within one Establishing Stick length; where there are only bad spots, the ball may be placed farther back without improving the lie.
  • Deliberately moving, rotating, knocking over or interfering with the T-Stick is prohibited.
  • If the T-Stick is accidentally displaced, play pauses until it is restored; no penalty is assessed automatically unless an applicable rule is ratified.

Proposed, not binding

  • Wrong club: +2 strokes, the shot is invalidated and replayed.
  • Accidental T-Stick displacement: restore the T-Stick, no penalty.
  • Deliberate T-Stick interference: loss of hole.
  • Dangerous shot: immediate suspension and official review.
OQ-010

Playoff drawsProposed

How is a drawn elimination match decided?

Proposed, not binding

  • Drawn elimination matches continue with sudden-death extra holes.
  • Equal-turn protection remains in effect.
OQ-011

Standings tiebreakersProposed

How are players separated when they finish level on league points?

Proposed, not binding

  • 1. Head-to-head results
  • 2. Round differential
  • 3. Hole differential
  • 4. Total match wins
OQ-012

ForfeitsPending

What are the scoring and standings consequences of forfeited and abandoned matches?

THL guidance: Forfeits and abandoned matches should be recorded as administrative results, without fabricated completed-hole statistics.

OQ-033

Damage during playPartially confirmed

What happens if a ribbon is damaged during play?

Confirmed

  • T-Stick damage: the referee suspends play, the T-Stick is repaired or replaced in its original position and orientation, and play resumes once it is safe. Completed shots, strokes and turn order are unchanged; accidental damage has no penalty (Rule 14.23).
OQ-034

Crossbar-to-bore clearancePartially confirmed

What are the exact crossbar-to-bore dimensions and tolerances?

Confirmed

  • Ratified standard, subject to future design review: slight observable movement, no excessive looseness, no binding, no detachment risk, and a captive crossbar during competitive play (Rule 14.27). Exact dimensions require prototype testing.
OQ-035

Captive crossbar retentionProposed

How is the crossbar kept captive during installation, play, transport and removal, so it cannot slide out?

Proposed, not binding

  • Experimental, not ratified: a wood-on-wood friction fit, with the crossbar passing directly through the shaft and no pins, screws, twist locks or other retaining hardware, removable by hand for transport and replacement.
  • A friction fit alone does not guarantee the crossbar stays captive under a strong ball impact, so it may conflict with rules 14.5 and 14.27. It needs prototype validation and a future ratification vote. See docs/design-notes/OQ-035-experimental-wood-on-wood-crossbar.md.
OQ-036

Bore reinforcementPending

How is the shaft reinforced around the bore to resist splitting and wear from repeated crossbar movement?

OQ-037

Installation torque limitsPending

What installation torque can the T-Stick and its anchor coupling safely take, and how is the shaft reinforced where it joins the anchor?

OQ-038

Temporary crossbar lockPending

Is a temporary locking mechanism needed to hold the crossbar rigid while the anchor is installed?

OQ-039

The signature CLACKPending

Does wood-on-wood crossbar movement produce a distinctive audible sound when a ball strikes the T-Stick? The sound is a design objective only; it must be validated by prototype testing and is never a scoring requirement. Safety and structural integrity take priority over sound.

OQ-040

Wear and durabilityPending

How does the T-Stick hold up over time: wear from repeated crossbar movement, structural fatigue and long-term durability?

OQ-042

Course Play holesPending

Does a Course Play event use conventional golf-course holes 1–9 or 1–18?

OQ-043

Course Play scoring structurePending

Does THL's three-round scoring (three holes to a round, three rounds to a match) apply to Course Play, and are ribbons used to identify course holes?

OQ-044

Course hazards, out of bounds and penaltiesPending

How do golf-course hazards, out-of-bounds and penalty rules apply in Course Play? Playoff and tournament rules for Course Play are also undecided.

OQ-045

Completing a course hole after contactPending

How do players complete a course hole after target contact, while keeping the equal-turn opportunity? This includes whether the 12-stroke maximum applies.

OQ-046

Installing the T-Stick between groupsPending

How is the T-Stick installed in and removed from the cup between groups, and who does it?

OQ-047

Sanctioning Course PlayPending

Can Course Play events be officially sanctioned by THL, and under what conditions? The T-Stick is not currently an approved replacement for conventional golf flagsticks.

OQ-048

Course cup adapterPending

What cup adapter fits existing golf cups and flagstick mountings? It must avoid damaging the cup or green, support the target securely, resist tipping and unintended rotation, be removable without tools that damage the surface, and be inspected and approved before use. Cups and flagstick systems differ between courses; no universal specification is assumed.

OQ-049

Course permission, liability and policiesPending

What course-operator permission, liability and insurance cover, and compliance with course operating policies does a Course Play event require, and how are putting surfaces protected?

OQ-050

Start Stick tee shot as a strokePending

Does the opening tee shot with the Start Stick count as a stroke toward a player's adjusted score?

OQ-051

Course Play order of playPending

Which player tees off first from the blue tees, and how is the order decided for each hole?

OQ-052

Courses without blue tee markersPending

Which tees are used at a course that has no blue tee markers, or names its tees differently?

OQ-053

Pace of playPending

What pace-of-play standards does the referee enforce, such as time limits per shot, hole or round, and what happens when play is too slow?

OQ-054

Referee appointment and authorityPending

How are referees appointed and qualified, how far does their authority extend, and can a referee's decision be reviewed or appealed?

OQ-058

Ribbon colors by roundProposed

Does the ribbon's color show the round, and in which colors?

Proposed, not binding

  • Red for round 1, white for round 2 and blue for round 3, to stand out more (THL, 17 November 2026, to be confirmed). This replaced an earlier suggestion of white, green and yellow-gold.
OQ-059

3v3 substitutionsPending

What exceptional substitution procedure, if any, applies once a 3v3 lineup is locked?

OQ-060

Prototype testing and certificationPending

What engineering, impact, field and manufacturing safety tests must the T-Stick pass before it is certified for official play?

OQ-061

Finish and shared upper assemblyProposed

Should the T-Stick have a natural-wood finish and rounded crossbar ends, and one wooden upper assembly shared by Field Play and Course Play with interchangeable mounts?

Proposed, not binding

  • A natural-wood finish, rounded smooth crossbar ends, and one standard wooden upper assembly with interchangeable mounting systems: the helical anchor for Field Play and a cup adapter for Course Play. Carried over from the earlier T-Stick dimensions proposal (OQ-025), which did not ratify these details.